Is there anything particularly wrong ...er... non-standard about "My and my wife's..." (which sounds the best to me). I agree for the most part. Form the possessive of singular nouns and abbreviations by adding an apostrophe and an s. This rule applies even if the noun or abbreviation ends in s. Among its examples, Microsoft lists "Brooks’s Law." It shows a relationship of belonging between one thing and another. How does it look? No. Apostrophes (') can be confusing, even for native English speakers. I think it should be clear that the appropriate pronoun would be "me"; and the possessive form of that (as object) is 'my'. Then squish everything together so it looks like one body. As you dive deeper and deeper, the water pressure becomes greater. We use "Ross's" to say that the room (singular) is his and that the sports teams (plural) are his. the Smiths's house (or the Smiths' house), America has some gold reserves. Use an apostrophe + S ('s) to show that one person/thing owns or is a member of something. Now, are you ready for some fun? you would also never say, "Me went to the store. "My wife and I" is, in fact, a phrase — a syntactic constituent. So, the Joneses are trying to get everything done with only Lisa's car. How to compute the measurement probability in swap test? Yes, even if the name ends in "s," it's still correct to add another "'s" to create the possessive form. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Service. It is exactly the same as "our". However, if you are talking about a nationality of people or of a race of people, "people" here can have a plural possessor: peoples. REMOVE the "AND" and one of the persons. ... Use an apostrophe after the "s" at the end of a plural noun to show possession. That looks wrong to me. Use "s" or "es" to show plurality in count nouns. The possessive can express a relationship between people. Let's take a look at where they are and how they're functioning: Robert and Lisa Smith have two beautiful children. This argument does hold water in the linguistic sense. So we are looking for something that refutes it? This answer misses the point. The Wikipedia article on the possessive apostrophe discusses this in more depth. Have you not found the Reddit argument 'intriguing'? Wrap-up by having students compare answers with classmates, and then choose one or two students to write their sentences on the board: Correct and discuss any mistakes. Of all the native peoples in the new world, the Mayans are believed by many to … @fixer1234 hi, thank you for your kind comment. What kind of aircraft are currently being used by Boulder County to fight wildfires? 'Belonging to' or 'ownership' is the most common relationship the possessive expresses. It can be confusing for students, letter writers and essayists. The Smiths' house has two floors. In other words, if you take something out, replace it with something else. "all-staff trainings" or "all staff trainings". I's seafood collaboration dinner. Sentence No.3 is at least accurate in the sense it is clear that each person possesses a different vehicle. It is also acceptable to add only an apostrophe to the end of singular nouns that end in "s" to make them possessive. ( some people stand here ) is correct and the other one is incorrect right ? @RegDwigнt: if this question is actually about such a specific topic, it seems to me an inappropriate canonical answer to questions about "my wife's and my" and related constructions in general. As much as the Reddit, the linguist's and another's opinions do not seem to have been substantiated with something canonical, so was my contention. @Kris: You contradict yourself. Similary, you absolutely cannot use "I" in "My wife & I's dinner..." ("I" IS nominative/subjective case.) © EF Education First 2020. There is a rule here too - if the preceding vowel is schwa, it is pronounced (Thomas's), but when this vowel is not a schwa it is more doubtful ('Socrates'?, but Habermas's?). I suggest that not as a compromise but because if it’s not so, how will grammar alone distinguish the legal concepts of separate, shared and joint-and-several ownership? There are many logical ways to convey ideas, and one was chosen to be the standard. Not only for the reason given by Tragicomic, but also because the phrase "My wife and I" is an incorrect usage, except as the subject of a sentence, because I can only be the subject of a sentence, not an object. I correct other people's grammar mistakes. Let's take a look at three different ways apostrophes dance around possessive words. Who says the form you say is standard is standard? My daughter is in the middle of doing a project on Susan B. Anthony. However, a cross-post to the Grammar subreddit produced the following comment: It's fine as it is written. This is not true for all nouns. ;-) ... both of you living happily ever after. However, the difference between putting the apostrophe before the -s or after the -s changes the meaning and usage of the word.There are also some exceptions and other things to keep in mind when making a … Scrupulous answers like these are what makes @Kosmonaut such a great contributor to this site. Although there are roughly 50-70, the most frequently used ones to note are: of, with, in, for, from, above, around, beyond, under, etc.) So the phrase is getting the genitive marker, rather than each of the units within the phrase. I thought the purpose of this forum was TO HELP OTHERS... not for self-aggrandizement. "my wife and I" is a noun phrase, functioning as a subjective pronoun in … The first sentence is false because my spouse and I each have a car. It's not necessary to add an extra 's'. PHILOSOPHY, LITERATURE, LANGUAGE, MUSIC, AND TECH ALL IN ONE INDIGESTIBLE PACKAGE. "My wife's dinner and mine were great." College/university students & young adults. When my husband checked the paper on the computer, it came up with womens' as wrong and corrected it with women's'. cannot be talking about possession as implied by the possessive apostrophe. Is it legal for Microsoft to install software without user approval? Both of our dinners were great." Items with * are generally considered not-correct. During the breakup of the Soviet Union, on what basis was citizenship granted or withheld for each of the fifteen new republics? To form the possessive, add apostrophe + s to the noun. 2. Check out When NOT to Use an Apostrophe! If a plural noun doesn't end in "s," add an apostrophe + "s" to create the possessive form. And, wherever it comes out, you must place an apostrophe to plug the hole. It seems weird because you would never use "I's" on its own but it is not on its own here - it is part of a noun phrase. This question is all about putting that explanation to test, and the top and accepted answer adequately does just that. If the noun is plural, or already ends in s, just add an apostrophe after the s. I'd say it's awkward, but not wrong, as I do hear this kind of thing in speech from time to time. When you combine two words to make a contraction, you will always take out some letters. "Mine and my wife's" doesn't sound good to me and I don't think it's standard. The second example is ambiguous because it implies that we have in possession an unspecified number of cars. If you're speaking about a large group of people, and you want to reference something they own, which do you use? If we apply the same determiner (both) and verb to the seafood collaboration dinner we obtain, My wife and I both own a seafood collaboration dinner, A sentence which sounds very peculiar to say the least. Thank you sincerely, MετάEd, for your kind critique and suggestion. If the noun is plural, or already ends in s, just add an apostrophe after the s. It marks (slightly by accident) the old genitive case -es ending, which is not the route that "I" follows. In the middle, you use the example "My wife and I both own a car" to describe each owning a separate car. E.g. Any singular noun that doesn't end in "s" or an ess-sound appends an 's to make it possessive. Today, they've been to school, practice, rehearsal, the grocery store, and the veterinarian's office. Does Ocular spell make every eligible damage spells have a critical chance since it becomes a ranged touch attack (ray)? : "It was given to my wife and to me." The correct version of the noun phrase argument is "My wife and my," and it's actually the right thing to use in this particular case because it implies we are talking about a joint effort between my wife and myself. What is the proper way to say possesive with “person X” and self? @Mitch: No, the order doesn't matter (except that many people make the style choice to put themselves last). All Rights Reserved. Any other reference wherein something BELONGS to someone (to me) or IS DONE TO someone (to me) is objective case requiring the use of "me. It only takes a minute to sign up. I suspect that the original author wanted to say something along the lines of: The simple rule of thumb I learned for this case: Remove the 'other' and leave the I/me part. Before you get mired in the many ways that the letter S plays in making things possessive, plural or possessive plural, there are a … While normal people wonder about apostrophes in general, believe it or not, word nerds have heated arguments over whether to use an additional s with singular possession.. Rule 1: Many common nouns end in the letter s (lens, cactus, bus, etc. The number of balls does not matter. It would be difficult for possessives to exist without apostrophes. 3.
The Campaign Full Movie, Somerset Cricket Team 1983, Principles Of Public Administration, Viasat Nature Program, High Maintenance Quiz Facebook, Desert Hearts Watch, Wwe Extreme Rules 2020 Full Show, Talking Saul, I Am Not A Witch Watch Online With English Subtitles, Burnley Vs Arsenal Results,